HomeMy WebLinkAbout2025-3-12 900 King Street Anthony Oliveri, PE, AI Engineers Letter570 Taxter Road, Suite 300
Elmsford, NY 10523
(914) 631-8600 phone
(914) 631-5769 fax
www.drepc.com
www.aiengineers.com
Improving Life. By Design.
Dolph Rotfeld Engineering
TO: Robert Goodman, Planning Board Chairman
& Planning Board Members.
FROM: Anthony Oliveri, P.E.
SUBJECT: 900 King Street Redevelopment
Rye Brook, New York
Sunrise Senior Living – Amended PUD Application
DATE: March 12, 2025
With regard to the above-mentioned project, this office has received and reviewed the
following:
1. Amended Site Plan Drawings, prepared by JMC, dated February 20, 2025;
2. Perkins Eastman Architectural Drawings, dated February 20, 2025;
3. MPFP Landscape Drawings, dated February 20, 2025;
4. JMC Preliminary Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan, latest revision February
20, 2025;
5. Application for Site Plan Approval, dated February 20, 2025;
6. NYSDEC Short EAF Form, dated February 20, 2025.
Our last comment memo regarding the previous site plan was dated March 6, 2021; it
appears many of those comments still apply and could be conditional to any resolution of
approval for the amended plan; thus our current comments are as follows:
1.) As per comment 2 of our project review letter dated March 6, 2021, we note that
the Applicant has indicated on the plans that the proposed Sanitary Sewer
Facilities are intended to be privately owned. The Applicant should confirm if the
WCDOH will allow these facilities to be privately owned, and if so, the Applicant
should be required to submit to the Village a formal operation and maintenance
agreement for the Sanitary Sewer Facilities, for Village review;
2.) As per comment 4 of our project review letter of March 6, 2021, we have not as
yet received information regarding demonstration of satisfactory Sanitary Sewer
scour velocity, for anticipated project sanitary sewer flows;
3.) As per comment 5 of our project review letter of March 6, 2021 regarding the
project Water Supply System, we note that the following water system upgrades
900 King Street Site Plan March 12, 2025
Page 2
Improving Life. By Design.
were to be made as a condition of both project approval, as well as the project
water supply provider’s “Willingness to Serve” letter:
a. Installation of interconnections to the Westchester Joint Water Works water
supply facilities both at King Street and at Anderson Hill Road, to be performed
by Veolia Water, and;
b. Installation of a water meter and vault on the 16-inch water main, on water
facilities located near Anderson Hill Road, in order to by-pass the existing 8-
inch water meter and vault that experiences significant peak flow head loss.
The cost of this improvement was to have been borne by the Applicant.
We note that these upgrades were scheduled to be performed during the year
2019. Please confirm if these water system upgrades and improvements have
been completed. We recommend that the above water system improvements, as
well as all components of the proposed project water distribution system, be
installed prior to issuance of any building permit for project buildings.
4.) As per comment 6 of our project review letter of March 6, 2021 regarding sanitary
sewer Inflow and Infiltration (I&I), we note that the Applicant had committed to an
I&I flow removal of 80,000 gpd. This flow reduction was to be accomplished
through either a monetary contribution, or through a specific project-based
mitigation, to be agreed upon by the Applicant and Village. Please provide an
update as to current I&I mitigation status.
5.) We have performed an initial review of the Preliminary Stormwater Pollution and
Prevention Plan (SWPPP), and we find that the preliminary SWPPP generally
addresses the requirements of the NYSDEC General Permit for Stormwater
Discharges. Based on this initial, preliminary review, we note the following:
a. Proposed condition stormwater facilities indicate the use of a sub-surface
infiltration system, which appears to cover an area of about 5,000 square feet.
The SWPPP notes that a conservative percolation rate of 1-inch per hour was
used in calculations, based on soil testing performed in (2) locations by JMC.
We were unable to determine the specific locations of these tests, nor their
proximity to the location of the proposed infiltration practice.
b. We note that as the proposed infiltration system appears to encompass an area
of about 5000 square feet, and in accordance with NYS Stormwater Design
Manual Appendix D – Infiltration Testing Requirements, we note that an
infiltration practice of 2,500-5,000 sf in area requires (3) infiltration tests to be
performed.
c. The project Geotechnical Report by AKRF indicates that prior infiltration tests
were performed (near PB-12 & 13), with average infiltration rates of 0.69 and
0.63 inches-per-hour. These rates are below the values obtained by JMC.
900 King Street Site Plan March 12, 2025
Page 3
Improving Life. By Design.
d. The AKRF Geotechnical report noted differing levels of groundwater being
recorded (approximately El.239 and El.245). The report recommended that
additional subsurface investigations be performed, in order to establish an
accurate groundwater level.
Based on a. – d. above, revised infiltration testing should be performed in the
specific area of the proposed infiltration system, with sufficient numbers of tests
performed. Additionally, the groundwater level in the area of the proposed
infiltration system should be investigated and more accurately defined prior to final
SWPPP submission.
6.) Please provide copies of the project NOI forms for review, when available.
7.) A more in-depth review of the project SWPPP must be performed prior to the
issuance of any project building permits. Please provide a copy of the final SWPPP
for detailed review when available.
8.) Plan Sheets C211 and C212 reference previous unit counts of (136) 1,2- and 3-
bedroom units, as well as (94) units of 1- and 2-bedroom assisted living/memory
care. These unit counts should be revised to reflect (126) and (85), respectively,
to be consistent with other plan sheets;
9.) As per comment 7 of our project review letter of March 6, 2021, the proposed fire
truck access plan and onsite fire protection plans must be reviewed by the Village
Fire Department and Building Department, for code compliance and operational
considerations;
10.) All other points noted in the Village’s Resolution of Approval dated August 10,
2021, not mentioned herein, should be again considered as part of any new
resolution of approval.
If you have any questions on the above, please advise.
Thank You
C: C. Bradbury
M. Nowak
S. Brown
J. Gray
R. Zitt
T. Orlando