HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016.12.08 F.P Clark Memo
To:
Date:
Subject:
As reque
submitte
Lot 1 of
Louis La
original
Housing
units to f
still inclu
property
within th
Section
Property
The 3.96
single-fa
the rear
elevation
of home
wetlands
within a
landscap
watercou
Project
The App
Pau
Boa
Dec
259
Sub
ested, we re
ed in support
the subdivis
arizza, contr
site plan ap
g (AFFH) uni
five AFFH un
udes two lots
y is situated
he R-15 Dis
135.35, Bloc
y Descriptio
6-acre (172,
amily home,
yard. Behin
n of North R
es along Eag
s located in t
drainage ea
ped area a
urses and we
t Description
plicant’s revi
ul S. Rosenb
ard of Truste
cember 8, 20
9 North Ridg
bdivision, Zo
eviewed subs
t of a three-l
ion into the F
ract vendee,
pplication for
ts. The revis
nits. The sub
s (Lot 2 and
at the inters
strict and the
ck 1, Lot 11 o
on
620 square-
driveway an
d the home,
Ridge Street d
gles Bluff an
the woodland
asement acro
around the
etlands most
n
sed proposa
erg, Mayor,
es of the Vill
016
ge Street –
oning Petiti
stantially rev
ot subdivisio
FAH District,
on behalf o
r Lot 1 soug
sed developm
bdivision rem
d Lot 3) for tw
section of W
e North Rid
on the Town
-foot) proper
nd curb cut,
, the lot slop
down to app
nd Rock Rid
ds below the
oss one of th
existing ho
tly located in
al is for a thre
and the
lage of Rye B
on and Site
vised site pla
on, and a site
, submitted b
of the prope
ght to constr
ment plan re
mains unchan
two single-fa
West Ridge D
ge Street S
of Rye Tax A
rty is partially
and a terrac
pes very stee
proximately th
dge Drive. T
e existing ho
he properties
me, the lot
n areas of low
ee-lot subdiv
Brook
e Plan Applic
ans and addi
e plan and p
by Pawling H
rty owner, D
uct eight Fa
educes the n
nged, and, in
amily market-
Drive and No
Scenic Road
Assessor’s M
y developed
ce at the bac
eply to the n
he elevation
The site drain
me and from
s on Eagles
t is natural
wer elevation
vision to crea
cation
itional inform
petition to re-
Holdings, LLC
Daniel Greto
air and Afford
umber of ho
n addition to L
-rate homes
orth Ridge S
Overlay Di
Map.
d with a one-
ck of the hom
northeast from
of the rear y
ns down-slo
m there into a
Bluff. Outsid
lly wooded,
n on the lot.
ate two single
mation
-zone
C and
. The
dable
using
Lot 1,
s. The
Street
strict,
-story
me in
m the
yards
ope to
a pipe
de the
with
e-
family bui
(Lot 1), w
AFFH, at
vehicles.
at this tim
wetlands a
Review
We review
site plans
include th
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10
11
12
13
14
15
lding lots (Lo
hich would b
tached, sing
The applica
e, a revised
and steep slo
wed the revi
, new corres
e following it
Full Environ
2016
Full Environ
Revised Fu
Application
Petition to t
Pawling Ho
May 15, 20
Application
Application
Site Plan S
Wetland De
Cold Spring
0. Storm Wat
Hudson, N
. Preliminary
Croton-on-
2. Report Me
developme
2016
3. Traffic Gen
Mastromon
4. Tree Inven
Certified A
5. Tree Inven
County Pla
ot 2 and Lot
be re-zoned
gle-family ho
ation also inc
site plan ap
opes permits
sed applicat
spondence, a
tems:
nmental Ass
nmental Ass
ull Environm
n for Subdivis
the Board of
oldings, LLC,
015
n for Site Plan
n for Site Plan
Submittal Rev
elineation an
g, N.Y., date
ter Report, p
N.Y., dated N
y Storm Wat
-Hudson, N.Y
emorandum r
ent on Lot 1 p
neration Esti
naco, P.E., P
ntory and Ma
Arborist, dated
ntory and Re
anning Depa
t 3) that wou
into the Fair
omes locate
cludes a zon
plication for
s by the Plan
tion, the zon
analyses and
sessment For
sessment For
ental Assess
sion Approva
f Trustees to
, prepared by
n Approval fo
n Approval fo
view Checkli
nd Functiona
ed October 26
repared by R
ovember 2, 2
ter Report, pr
Y., dated Oc
regarding the
prepared by
mates Repo
P.C., Croton-
apping for En
d February 2
moval Plan,
rtment, date
2
uld remain in
r and Afforda
ed in a sing
ing petition f
Lot 1. The re
nning Board.
ning petition,
d supporting
rm dated Jan
rm dated Jan
sment Form
al
Re-Zone Ne
y Clark Neur
or Lot 1, revi
or Lot 1
st for Lot 1
l Assessmen
6, 2015
Ralph G. Mas
2016
repared by R
tober 19, 20
e estimated n
RH Consulti
rt and Accide
-on-Hudson,
ntire Property
2, 2016
prepared by
d April 20, 20
n the R-15 D
able (FAH) D
gle building,
for the afford
evised Lot 1
, the prelimin
materials su
nuary 7, 201
nuary 7, 201
dated Decem
ew Lot 1 into
ringer, R.A.,
ised Novemb
nt prepared b
stromonaco,
Ralph G. Mas
15
number of sc
ing, White P
ent Data, pre
N.Y., dated
y prepared by
y Anthony Za
016
District, and a
District for de
and surfac
dable housin
site plan req
nary subdivi
ubmitted by t
6, revised N
6
mber , 2016
o the FAH Dis
Mamaronec
ber 23, 2016
by Tim Miller
, P.E., P.C.,
stromonaco,
chool childre
lains, N.Y., d
epared by Ra
March 4, 20
y Paul D. Mu
aino, RLA, W
a third buildin
evelopment o
e parking fo
ng lot (Lot 1)
quires appro
sion plat, re
the Applican
ovember 23
strict from
k, N.Y., date
6
r Associates
Croton-on-
P.E., P.C.,
n generated
dated March
alph G.
016
uscariello,
Westchester
ng lot
of five
or 13
), and
val of
evised
nt that
,
ed
, Inc.,
by
16,
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
6. Energy and
Mamarone
7. Lighting Pl
8. Response
P.C., Croto
9. Letter to th
Hudson, N
0. Review Me
White Plain
. Review Me
White Plain
2. Review Me
White Plain
3. Memorand
Neuringer,
4. Memorand
dated Octo
5. Front and
6. “Topograp
N.Y., dated
7. “Preliminar
N.Y., dated
8. “Fire Truck
Hudson, N
9. Landscape
Departmen
0. Landscape
Departmen
. Tree Inven
County Pla
2. Engineer’s
P.C., Croto
Sheet Num
1 of 1
1 of 1
1 of 1
1 of 1
1 of 1
1 of 1
d Zoning Me
eck, N.Y., dat
an for Lot 1,
Letter to Jam
on-on-Hudso
he Board of T
N.Y., dated Se
emorandum
ns, N.Y., dat
emorandum
ns, N.Y., dat
emorandum
ns, N.Y., dat
dum to Frede
R.A., Mama
dum to the Bo
ober 25, 201
Rear Perspe
hical Survey
d January 15
ry Plat,” prep
d July 27, 20
k – Enter Site
N.Y., no date
e Plan, prepa
nt, dated Nov
e Plan, prepa
nt, dated Apr
ntory and Re
anning Depa
s Plans (Orig
on-on-Hudso
mber She
Site
Sigh
Fire
Fire
Fire
Fire
emorandum f
ted April 8, 2
prepared by
mes Natarell
on, N.Y., date
Trustees from
eptember 16
to the Village
ted Decembe
to the Plann
ted May 4, 20
to the Plann
ted May 23, 2
erick P. Clark
aroneck, N.Y
oard of Trust
6
ective Rende
y of Property,
5, 2016
pared by Ral
015
e,” prepared
ared by Anth
vember 7, 20
ared by Anth
ril 21, 2016
moval Plan,
rtment, date
inal Lot 1 Sit
on, N.Y.:
eet Title
e Plan Fair A
ht Lines
e Truck Back
e Truck Back
e Truck in fro
e Truck in fro
3
for Lot 1, pre
2016
y RAB Lightin
i, P.E., DRE
ed May 16, 2
m Ralph G. M
6, 2015
e Administra
er 6, 2016
ing Board fro
016
ing Board fro
2016
k Associates
Y., dated Dec
tees from Cla
erings of the 5
,” prepared b
ph G. Mastro
by Ralph G.
ony Zaino, R
016
ony Zaino, R
prepared by
d November
te Plan), pre
ffordable Ho
k Out South
k Out North
om North
om South
epared by Cla
ng, Northval
from Ralph
2016
Mastromonac
ator from Dol
om Dolph Ro
om Dolph Ro
(Marilyn Tim
cember 2, 20
ark Neuringe
5-unit Lot 1 B
by Link Land
omonaco, P.
. Mastromon
RLA, Westch
RLA, Westch
y Anthony Za
r 16, 2016
pared by Ra
ousing
ark Neuringe
e, N.J., date
G. Mastrom
co, P.E., P.C
ph Rotfeld E
otfeld Engine
otfeld Engine
mpone-Moha
016
er, R.A., Mam
Building rece
Surveyors,
.E., P.C., Cro
aco, P.E., P
hester County
hester County
aino, RLA, W
alph G. Mastr
Dated
10/27/
4/7/20
4/7/20
4/7/20
4/7/20
4/7/20
er, R.A.,
d March 4, 2
onaco, P.E.,
C., Croton-on
Engineering,
eering, P.C.,
eering, P.C.,
amed) from C
maroneck, N
eived 12/2/16
P.C., Mahop
oton-on-Hud
.C., Croton-o
y Planning
y Planning
Westchester
romonaco, P
/2015
016
016
016
016
016
2016
,
n-
P.C.,
Clark
N.Y.,
6
pac,
son,
on-
P.E.,
33
34
35
3. Engineer’s
P.C., Croto
Sheet Num
1 of 8
4. Architect’s
Architect, M
Sheet Num
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
S1
S1
S2
5. Architect’s
Architect, M
Sheet Num
1
2
3
4
5
7
S1
S1
s Plans (Revi
on-on-Hudso
mber She
Alte
Plans (Origi
Mamaroneck
mber She
Fron
Rea
Left
Righ
Fou
Firs
Sec
Cro
Cro
Elev
Plans (Revi
Mamaroneck
mber She
Elev
Elev
Elev
Fou
Firs
Sec
Cro
Cro
ised Lot 1 Si
on, N.Y.:
eet Title
ernate Gradin
S
inal Lot 1 Bu
k, N.Y.:
eet Title
nt Elevation
ar Elevation B
t Elevation B
ht Elevation
undation – Bu
st Floor – Bui
cond Floor –
oss Section th
oss Section th
(
vations Build
sed Lot 1 Bu
k, N.Y.:
eet Title
vations
vations
vation Calcu
Diagram
undation Plan
st Floor Build
cond Floor B
oss Section th
oss Section th
4
te Plan), pre
ng Plan Nort
Street Devel
uildings and S
Buildings 1a
Buildings 1
Buildings 1 an
Buildings 1 a
uildings 1 an
ildings 1 and
Buildings 1 a
hrough Site
hrough Site
(with Landsc
dings 1 and 2
uilding and S
ulations, Fire
ms, Site Secti
n
ding Plan
uilding Plan
hrough Site
hrough Site
epared by Ra
th Ridge
lopment
Site Plan, pre
D
and 2 11
and 2 2/
nd 2 2/
and 2 2/
nd 2 2/
d 2 2/
and 2 2/
3/
cape) 3/
2 3/
Site Plan), pre
D
11
11
Ladder
tion 11
11
11
11
3/
alph G. Mast
Dated
11/4/1
epared by C
ated
1/11/15 rev.
/3/16 rev. 2/1
/3/16 rev. 2/1
/3/16 rev. 2/1
/3/16 rev. 2/1
/3/16 rev. 2/1
/3/16 rev. 2/1
/11/16
/11/16
/24/16
epared by C
ated
1/1/16
1/1/16
1/3/16
1/1/16
1/1/16
1/1/16
/11/16
tromonaco, P
6
lark Neuring
2/25/16
18/16
18/16
18/16
18/16
18/16
18/16
lark Neuring
P.E.,
er
er
Please no
following c
1. Add
requ
Lot 1
2. SEQ
1 sit
re-zo
origi
3. Alte
stee
slop
of th
prac
amo
4. Rev
com
plan
base
seem
rede
the
prop
cars
need
Afte
reco
sma
furth
perp
That
cour
furth
coul
east
ote that our
comments re
itional Infor
uirements of C
1.
QRA Review
e plan as pa
one propose
nal site plan
eration of La
ep slopes, an
es for approv
he revised s
cticable to re
ount of new s
vised Site P
mpared to the
ns to reduce
ements of th
ms to us tha
esigned or el
Trustees, th
posed 40-foo
s in tandem
d for 10 surfa
r including
onsidering th
aller parking
her north on
pendicular to
t type of par
rt on a single
her away fro
d be done w
t.
review is lim
egarding the
mation Need
Chapter 235
w. An environ
art of the com
ed Lot 1 into
should be u
and and Top
nd will be req
val of a Stee
site plan for
egulated slop
teep slopes,
Plan. The
e original site
visual impa
e units. It ma
at may not b
iminated. A
is would allo
ot unit length
in the base
ace parking s
garages to
e location of
areas, perha
n the site. T
o an extende
rking area of
e-family lot t
m the Sceni
without creat
mited to plan
applications
ded. A tree
of the Villag
nmental revie
mbined action
the FAH Dis
pdated as ne
pography. T
quired to com
p Slopes Wo
Lot 1 shoul
pes and the
and utilizatio
revised Lot
e plan. Howe
acts and site
ay mean add
e necessary
s has been p
ow a reductio
h, with an op
ement, if a re
spaces.
house 10
f any remain
aps located
The parking
ed driveway
f two, three
than the prop
c Road. Fro
ting addition
5
ning, zoning
s:
preservation
e Code shou
ew pursuant
n of the site p
strict. All the
ecessary for
The revised s
mply with the
ork Permit. W
d ensure th
vegetation o
on of large ret
t 1 site pla
ever, we con
e disturbance
ding 1 to 2 fe
y if the entry
pointed out b
on in the am
pen baseme
esident desi
of the req
ing surface p
on either sid
spaces co
servicing th
or four cars
posed 13-ca
om a quick s
nal topograph
g and environ
n and protecti
uld be provid
to SEQRA i
plan, subdivi
information a
r the revised
site plan for
e Village Cod
We continue
at the plan
on these slo
taining walls.
n reduces
ntinue to reco
e even furth
eet of width
y and stair ha
by the Plann
mount of surf
ent plan, it w
ired. This w
quired parki
parking by pe
de of the bu
uld be loca
he garages a
is visually m
ar lot, and wo
sketch and g
hy and visua
nmental issu
ion plan that
ded for the re
is required fo
ision, and m
and analyse
site plan.
Lot 1 would
de regulation
to recomme
causes the
opes, the cre
.
disturbance
ommend rev
her by includ
to each of th
all on the ba
ing Board, a
face parking
would be pos
would potenti
ng spaces,
erhaps brea
ilding, which
ated directly
at the rear o
more like par
ould locate t
grading analy
al impacts d
ues. We hav
complies wit
evised site pla
or the revise
ap amendme
s provided fo
be located o
ns regarding
nd that the d
least disturb
eation of the
of steep s
vising the bu
de garages i
he units; tho
asement leve
and at least o
proposed. A
ssible to par
ally eliminat
we recomm
king it up int
h could be m
adjacent to
of the buildin
rking in a pa
the parking a
ysis, we belie
down-slope t
ve the
th the
an for
ed Lot
ent to
or the
on the
steep
design
bance
least
lopes
uilding
n the
ugh it
el are
one of
At the
k two
te the
mend
to two
moved
o and
ng(s).
arking
areas
eve it
to the
5. Soil
issu
on t
prop
be
man
and
com
blas
6. Tran
by o
Trus
Lot 1
7. Incr
loca
that
the r
Star
be h
deve
8. Lan
Distr
Boa
deve
othe
hom
Lot 1
All th
inclu
incre
the
incre
park
front
topo
incre
s. Based on
es related to
the site is 0
posed Lot 1.
necessary
nagement pla
the mitigati
mpliance with
sting and/or r
nsportation.
our traffic en
stees dated N
1 site plan.
rease in Ene
al energy res
the original
requirements
r rated, low–e
high efficien
elopment of t
d Use and Z
rict to the Fa
rd of Truste
elop the revi
erwise be all
mes in the Vil
1 will be 4 tim
hree new lot
udes special
eased front y
FAH Distric
eased densit
king area an
t property li
ography of t
eases impac
n the informa
o constructio
0 to 6 feet, a
The Applica
during cons
an should in
on measure
h the Rye B
rock removal
. Recently s
gineers who
November 3,
ergy Use. D
sources. The
two-building
s of the curre
energy dema
ncy gas-fired
the revised L
Zoning. The
ir and Afford
es to waive
ised site pla
owed on Lo
lage. Though
mes the size o
ts will be loca
regulations to
yard setback
ct regulations
ty, the revise
d the trash
ne and the
the site and
cts to the Sc
ation provide
n. However,
and the surv
ant should cl
struction. If
clude discus
es for the im
Brook Village
.
submitted tra
provided co
2016. This m
Development
e April 8, 201
developmen
ent New Yor
and LED fixt
d boilers. Th
Lot-1 site pla
e Proposed A
able Housing
the underly
n of five AF
t 1, in the in
h an increase
of a 15,000 s
ated within th
o help protec
ks and 35-foo
s would allo
ed site plan
storage loca
Scenic Roa
d visual imp
enic Road a
6
ed in the EAF
the EAF ind
vey indicate
larify if blast
rock remo
ssion regard
mpacts relate
e Code and
affic data and
omments in
memorandum
t of the thre
16 memoran
nt on Lot 1 w
rk State Ener
ures for nigh
he Applicant
an.
Action include
g (FAH) Distr
ying dimensio
FFH resident
nterest of en
ed density is
square-foot m
he Street Sc
ct the scenic
ot vegetative
ow the Trust
raises conce
ation in the f
ad. While the
acts to neig
and neighbor
F, soils on th
dicates that t
es the prese
ing or other
oval will be
ing the pote
ed to noise,
d best mana
d sight dista
a separate m
m includes co
ee new lots
ndum from th
would be con
rgy Code. Al
ht lighting, an
t should cla
es a zone ch
rict. The FAH
onal requirem
tial units, wh
ncouraging t
allowed on
minimum-size
cenic Road O
qualities of N
buffers alon
tees to alte
erns regardi
front yard of
e new site
ghbors adjac
rs to the wes
he property s
the average
ence of rock
methods of
e required,
ential impacts
air quality a
agement pra
nce informat
memorandum
omments reg
will increase
he Applicant’
nstructed in c
l appliances
nd the heatin
rify if this w
hange for Lo
H District reg
ments of the
hich is more
he developm
the lot, it sho
ed lot in the R
Overlay Distri
North Ridge S
ng the street
er required s
ng the locat
f the lot only
plan reduce
cent to the
st of the site
hould not pr
depth to be
k outcrops o
rock remova
the constru
s of rock rem
and vibration
actices rega
tion was revi
m to the Boa
arding the re
e the deman
’s architect s
conformance
would be En
ng systems w
would be tru
ot 1 from the
ulations allo
e R-15 Distr
units than w
ment of affor
ould be noted
R-15 district.
ict (SROD), w
Street that in
frontage. Th
setbacks to
tion of the 1
y 25 feet from
es impacts t
rear of Lot
. We recomm
esent
drock
n the
al will
uction
moval
n and
arding
iewed
ard of
evised
nd for
states
e with
nergy
would
ue for
R-15
ow the
rict to
would
rdable
d that
which
nclude
hough
allow
3-car
m the
o the
1, it
mend
furth
neig
9. Com
that
sing
anal
the r
Altho
plan
rega
too l
in th
The
rega
10. Visu
a so
resid
use
grou
11. Con
arise
prov
and
impa
need
cons
rock
plan
iden
We look fo
her revision
ghbors to the
mmunity Ch
would be ge
le-family hom
ysis of the nu
revised Lot 1
ough the nu
n, the size of
arding the ori
large and ou
he number of
Rye Brook
ard to emerg
ual Impacts.
ource of visu
dences down
of shielded,
und for night-
nstruction. T
e during co
vided into a
estimate the
acts, such a
d for materia
struction site
k removal or
, demonstra
tify by specif
orward to disc
of the site p
west of the
haracter. Th
enerated by
mes after sub
umber of sch
site plan and
mber of buil
the single b
iginal Lot 1 s
ut of characte
f units propos
Emergency
ency service
. Night lightin
ual impacts t
nhill, especia
residential-t
lighting on th
The location
onstruction.
draft constr
e impacts of
as increased
als storage a
, increased
blasting, etc
ate complian
fic best practi
cussion with
plan to elim
site.
he Applicant
developmen
bdivision of t
hool children t
d the single-f
dings and th
uilding on Lo
site plan indic
er with the ne
sed or break
Services Ta
es capacity a
ng of the com
to residences
lly in the win
type light LE
e site.
and terrain o
The applica
uction mana
construction
traffic, incre
and staging a
noise, vibrat
c. will be elim
nce with Villa
ces to be imp
the Board of
7
inate or red
provided an
nt of the orig
the existing lo
that would be
family homes
he unit densi
ot 1 was incr
cated that th
eighborhood
king up the u
ask Force w
and access to
mmon parking
s surroundin
ter when dec
ED fixtures m
of Lot 1 raise
ant should e
agement and
on Lot 1 of
eased deman
areas, impac
tion, potentia
minated or m
age Code r
plemented.
f Trustees.
duce impacts
estimate of
inally-propos
ot. The App
e generated b
s on the two m
ity on Lot 1
reased by ad
e original bu
d. We recomm
nits into two
ill review the
o the new res
g area of the
g the lot. To
ciduous trees
mounted no
e concerns re
expand the
d logistics pl
the revised s
nd for parkin
cts to air qua
al erosion an
mitigated by
requirements
s to the sce
the number
sed eight AF
plicant should
by the five-un
market-rate lo
is reduced i
dding the fifth
uildings were
mend consid
smaller build
e revised Lo
sidences.
revised Lot 1
o eliminate e
s are leafless
higher than
egarding the
constructio
lan. This pla
site plan, and
ng, construct
lity, security
nd sedimenta
the construc
s regarding
enic road an
r of schoolch
FFH units and
d provide up
nit developm
ots.
n the revised
h unit. Comm
e considered
dering a redu
dings.
ot 1 site plan
1 site plan m
excessive gla
s, we recom
12 feet from
impacts that
on task sch
an should id
d explain ho
tion traffic ro
and safety o
ation, potenti
ction manage
construction
d the
hildren
d two
dated
ent of
d site
ments
to be
uction
n with
ay be
are to
mend
m the
t may
edule
entify
w the
outing,
on the
ial for
ement
, and
cc: Ro
Ch
Mi
Je
Cl
Ra
J:\DOCS2\500\R
obert I. Good
hristopher Br
ichal Nowak
ennifer L. Gra
ark Neuringe
alph G. Mast
Rye Brook\538.630.2
dman and the
radbury, Villa
, Village Eng
ay, Esq., Villa
er, R.A. for th
tromonaco, P
259 North Ridge Stre
M
S
e Village Pla
age Administ
gineer/Super
age Attorney
he Applicant
P.E.
reet.Subdivision and
8
Marilyn Timp
Senior Assoc
anning Board
trator
intendent of
y
Site Plan.Memo5.m
pone-Moham
ciate/Plannin
d
Public Work
mtm.docm
med, ASLA, A
ng/Environm
ks
AICP
ent