HomeMy WebLinkAbout2010-05-11 - Board of Trustees Meeting Minutes REGULAR MEETING
VILLAGE OF RYE BROOK
BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING
VILLAGE HALL, 938 KING STREET
TUESDAY, MAY 111 2010-7:30 P.M.
AGENDA
7:15 P.M.– Executive Session–Update on Litigation
ROLL CALL
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
REPORT
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
(1) Public Hearing to consider a proposed Tier III Home Occupation Permit for a
dental office at 267 North Ridge Street
(2) Public Hearing to consider a proposed local law amending Chapter 212 of the
Village of Rye Brook Village Code regarding sprinklers
RESOLUTIONS:
(1) Considering a Tier III Home Occupation Permit for a dental office at 267
North Ridge Street
(2) Considering a proposed local law to amend Chapter 212 of the Village of Rye
Brook Village Code regarding sprinklers
(3) Referring a proposed site plan amendment regarding the BelleFair meeting
house to the Planning Board for report and recommendation
(4) Considering the use of Village streets for a BBHS senior class pre-prom event
(5) Considering an appointment of a Recreation Leader
(6) Considering appointments to various Boards, Committee and Commissions
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 1
(7) Setting a public hearing to consider a new Fire Services Contract with the
Village of Port Chester
(8) Setting a public hearing to consider proposed amendments to the Village
Code regarding jurisdiction over affordable housing approval
(9) Considering the approval of minutes: February 9, 2010; February 23, 2010;
March 9, 2010; March 23, 2010; April 27, 2010
ADMINISTRATOR'S REPORT
OLD BUSINESS
NEW BUSINESS
DISCUSSION ITEMS:
(1) Village Code requirements regarding dead trees
ACTION ON NON-AGENDA MATTERS SUBJECT TO THE CONSENT OF THE
TRUSTEES PRESENT AT THE MEETING
THE NEXT REGULAR TRUSTEES MEETINGS: May 25 and June 8, 2010
BOARD: Trustee Michael S. Brown
Trustee Toby S. Marrow
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein
STAFF: Christopher Bradbury, Village Administrator
David Burke, Assistant to the Village Administrator
Gregory Austin, Chief of Police
Edward Beane, Esq., Village Counsel
Michal Nowak, Acting Village Engineer
Fred Seifert, Public Access Coordinator
Paula Patafio, Meeting Secretary
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein welcomed everyone to the regular meeting of the Board of
Trustees. With the consensus of the Board she asked to take a matter out of order. She
noted that Police Officer Kiernan Mutchler was appointed at a previous meeting. He was
introduced to the Board and the public, as Rye Brook's newest officer. Officer Mutchler
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 2
thanked the Board for the opportunity, and stated that he looked forward to working with
Rye Brook for many years to come.
Mayor Feinstein called for the first item on the agenda:
PUBLIC HEARINGS:
(1) PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A PROPOSED TIER III HOME
OCCUPATION PERMIT FOR A DENTAL OFFICE AT 267 NORTH
RIDGE STREET
Mayor Feinstein noted that the applicant had requested an adjournment. Edward
Beane, Esq., Village Counsel, noted that there were a number of issues to be
resolved, and the request for adjournment was a mutual agreement between the
Village and the Applicant. The public hearing would be placed on the May 25th
agenda. Mayor Feinstein noted that the applicant was aware of the Ridge Street
repaving project for many years. There are issues that are now being vetted, and a
decision must be made either for or against the application. As the applicant had
requested a prior adjournment, Mayor Feinstein noted that she was glad that his
was a mutual request. She asked for a motion to adjourn.
On a motion made by Trustee Jeffrey Rednick, and seconded by Trustee Michael
Brown, the matter was adjourned to the May 25, 2010 Board of Trustees Meeting.
Mr. David Burke, Assistant to the Village Administrator, called the roll:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
(2) PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A PROPOSED LOCAL LAW
AMENDING CHAPTER 212 OF THE VILLAGE OF RYE BROOK
VILLAGE CODE REGARDING SPRINKLERS
Mr. Christopher Bradbury, Village Administrator, noted that the Rye Brook Code
regarding sprinklers exceeds the New York State law. The sprinkler or is a
supplement to the State Code. Mr. Bradbury reviewed the changes to the
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 3
proposed local law for the Board, noting that the Village's standards and Code are
more restrictive than the State's.
On Trustee Paul Rosenberg, and seconded by Trustee Jeffrey Rednick, the public
hearing was opened.
Mr. Burke called the roll:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
Mayor Feinstein called for members of the public wishing to address the Board on
this matter. There being no one, she turned to the Board for comments and
questions.
Trustee Rosenberg noted that the amendments were being made with the safety
and health of the Rye Brook residents in mind. Certain provisions of our local
law are more restrictive than the New York State law. The amendments now
cover two-story homes.
There being no further discussion, Mayor Feinstein called for a motion to close
the public hearing.
On a motion made by Trustee Michael Brown, and seconded by Trustee Jeffrey
Rednick, the public hearing was closed.
The roll was called:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
Mayor Feinstein called for the resolution regarding Chapter 212 of the Village's Code:
RESOLUTIONS:
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 4
(2) CONSIDERING A PROPOSED LOCAL LAW TO AMEND CHAPTER 212
OF THE VILLAGE OF RYE BROOK VILLAGE CODE REGARDING
SPRINKLERS
Mr. Bradbury read the following resolution:
RESOLUTION
CONSIDERING A PROPOSED LOCAL LAW TO AMEND CHAPTER 212 OF
THE VILLAGE OF RYE BROOK VILLAGE CODE REGARDING
SPRINKLERS
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees proposed a local law amending
Chapter 212 of the Village of Rye Brook Village Code regarding Sprinklers; and
WHEREAS, on May 11, 2010 the Board of Trustees opened a public
hearing on the subject Local Law and at which time all persons interested were
given an opportunity to speak on behalf of or in opposition to said Local Law and
the public hearing was closedon May 11, 2010.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees
hereby approves a local law amending Chapter 212 of the Village of Rye Brook
Village Code regarding Sprinklers.
On a motion made by Trustee Rednick, and seconded by Trustee Brown, the
resolution was adopted.
The roll was called:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
The next resolution on the agenda was called before the Board:
(3) REFERRING A PROPOSED SITE PLAN AMENDMENT REGARDING
THE BELLEFAIR MEETING HOUSE TO THE PLANNING BOARD FOR
REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION
Mr. Bradbury read the following resolution:
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 5
RESOLUTION
REFERRING A PROPOSED SITE PLAN AMENDMENT REGARDING THE
BELLEFAIR MEETING HOUSE TO THE
VILLAGE PLANNING BOARD FOR REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION
WHEREAS, The BelleFair Homeowners Association, Inc. has submitted
a proposed site plan amendment for modifications to change the use of a portion
of the retail space to a place of public assembly to use as a community room; and
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees has final site plan authority pursuant
to § 209-1(A)(1); and
WHEREAS, the BelleFair Homeowners Association, Inc. has requested
waivers of several required submissions of a full site plan application; and
WHEREAS, the Building Inspector and Acting Engineer have reviewed
the application and recommend acceptance of said application for review, and the
granting of the requested waivers other than the site plan documents submitted
with the application initially and subsequently.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Board of Trustees
hereby refers the proposed site plan amendment to the Planning Board for report
and recommendation; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees of the Village of
Rye Brook, shall hold a public hearing on June 22, 2010 at 7:30 p.m. at 32
Garibaldi Place, Rye Brook, New York to consider the proposed site plan
amendment.
Stephen D. Frank, Esq., legal counsel for the BelleFair Homeowners Association,
gave a brief overview of the nature of the application. He noted that when
BelleFair was originally approved there was a special building constructed where
the contractor conducted the sale of the homes in this development. When the
sponsor ceased using the space for sales it became vacant. The Homeowners
Association is looking to use this space as an annex to the Meeting House. Mr.
Frank also noted that there is a meeting house and a multi-purpose building, a day
care center and a deli-market. The Meeting House is used as a library, gym, and
for meetings. There is a lot more that can be offered to the BelleFair residents.
Parking is not an issue. There is parking around the Village Green, and several
parking areas that can be utilized. There will be more than adequate parking for
this change in use. The Homeowners Board has commissioned a parking analysis.
The analysis came to the conclusion that the parking for the change of use is more
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 6
than sufficient. BelleFair residents will be using this space and they would be the
first ones to complain if there is not sufficient parking. The Board will control the
hours of operation, events held in this space, and use of the building. It is the
applicant's hope that the Board of Trustees will move the application along as
expeditiously as possible.
Mayor Feinstein noted the Board of Trustees is referring the application to the
Planning Board for review and recommendation. Nothing will change as far as
the particular space is concerned. She did question what would happen if there
were parties/events going on in both buildings at the same time. How would this
effect the parking? This is an issue to be discussed by the Planning Board.
Regarding the waivers that the applicant had requested, given the nature of this
application and the fact that the site and configuration are not changing, she felt
that the waivers were appropriate.
Trustee Michael Brown noted that some events can have 40, 50 or 85 guests. It is
quite a distance for people to walk across the Village Green to the parking areas.
The maximum distance is approximately 450 to 500 feet from parking to the
building. Other than the parking issue, he felt that this is a great opportunity for
the residents.
Trustee Rosenberg echoed Trustee Brown's comments. He noted that he
understood that both buildings would have parties. He stated that in his opinion
the parking is an issue only because it is a far walk.
Mr. Bradbury noted that this matter has not been referred to the Village's outside
consultant. There is a policy question about the use of parking in the front of the
homes. He also felt that the issues were fairly dealable.
Mayor Feinstein noted that if the Planning Board had an issue with any of the
requirements, they will find a way to refer that issue back to the Village Board.
She pointed out that the June 22"d Board of Trustees Meeting was scheduled to be
held at the A.J. Posillipo Center at 32 Garibaldi Place.
Trustee Rosenberg amended resolution to note date of public hearing at Senior
Center. The motion was seconded by Trustee Rednick.
Mr. Burke called the roll:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 7
(4) CONSIDERING THE USE OF VILLAGE STREETS FOR A BBHS
SENIOR CLASS PRE-PROM EVENT
Mr. Bradbury read the following resolution:
RESOLUTION
CONSIDERING THE USE OF VILLAGE STREETS
FOR A BBHS SENIOR CLASS PRE-PROM EVENT
RESOLVED, that the use of Birch Lane from Red Roof Drive to Old
Orchard on Thursday, June 10, 2010 from 4:15PM to 6:30PM for the Blind Brook
Senior Class Pre Prom at 2 Birch Lane is hereby approved with the terms to be
established by the Rye Brook Police Department, including the hiring of an off
duty police officer during the duration of the event.
Mr. Bradbury noted that there were two options for this pre-prom event. The less
intrusive one was to hold it at the cul-de-sac that has access to Pine Ridge Park,
where pictures would be taken. Notification of the event will be sent to all
residents in the area.
Chief Greg Austin addressed the Board. He noted that closing the street is to
accommodate the parking. There will be barricades and the area will be blocked
off. He agreed that the cul-de-sac is a better location for parking.
Mr. Bradbury noted that he had received an email from the Lubkm family. This
is the cul-de-sac near Pine Ridge Park. Limiting vehicular access enhances the
safety of the people using the streets, however, it is an inconvenience for the
residents of this area. Because of the proximity to Pine Ridge Park, this area is
used for similar events, such as during Halloween. The homeowners on these
streets should be allowed to pass during the temporary road closure.
Trustee Rosenberg noted that the homeowners are banned from coming and going
to their own homes during these types of events, and it doesn't seem fair. He
suggested that an off-duty police office should be hired by the event planner.
Trustee Brown agreed that the hiring of a police officer should be a condition to
the approval of the resolution. It was noted that the fee is $50.00 per hour with a
two hour minimum. Denying a resident access to their home, no matter how
limited, is a lot to ask.
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 8
Chief Austin agreed that it would be a good idea to have an officer at the scene.
Mr. Bradbury read the modified resolution.
On a motion by Trustee Brown, and seconded by Trustee Rednick, the resolution
was adopted as amended.
The roll was called:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
(5) CONSIDERING AN APPOINTMENT OF A RECREATION LEADER
Mr. Bradbury read the following resolution:
RESOLUTION
CONSIDERING AN APPOINTMENT OF RECREATION LEADER
RESOLVED, that Kyle P. Thornton of 16 Nepperhan Avenue, Hastings,
New York, is hereby appointed to the position of Recreation Leader with the
Village of Rye Brook, subject to the Civil Service procedures of the State of New
York; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the annual salary is $42,855 with an
effective start date of May 12, 2010.
On a motion made by Trustee Rosenberg, and seconded by Trustee Rednick, the
resolution was adopted.
The roll was called:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 9
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
(6) CONSIDERING APPOINTMENTS TO VARIOUS BOARDS,
COMMITTEE AND COMMISSIONS
Mr. Bradbury read the following resolutions:
RESOLUTIONS
CONSIDERING APPOINTMENTS TO VARIOUS
BOARDS, COMMITTEES AND COMMISSIONS
APPOINTMENTS TO THE AIRPORT ADVISORY COUNCIL
RESOLVED, that Richard Goldstein of 5 Heritage Court is hereby reappointed
for a term that shall expire on the first Monday in April 2011; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Nancy Ruskin of 7 Doral Greens Drive West is
hereby reappointed for a term that shall expire on the first Monday in April 2011; and be
it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Dee Schmidt of 15 High Point Circle is hereby
reappointed for a term that shall expire on the first Monday in April 2011; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Marcia Teschner is hereby reappointed
Chairperson.
APPOINTMENTS TO THE TRAFFIC COMMISSION
RESOLVED, that Paul Brandeis of 12 Country Ridge Circle is hereby appointed
for a term that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Jody Braclnnan of 76 Tamarack Road is hereby
appointed for a term that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Gerry Appelbaum of 1 Country Ridge Drive is
hereby appointed to an unexpired term that will expire on the first Monday in April,
2011; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Tina Blank is hereby appointed Chairperson.
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 10
APPOINTMENTS TO THE ADVISORY COUNCIL ON ENVIRONMENTAL
CONSERVATION
RESOLVED, that Margaret Veith-Heib of 91 Valley Terrace is hereby appointed
for a term that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Miriam Raphael of 9 Reunion Road is hereby
appointed for a term that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that David Bacchioni of 25 Winding Wood Road is
hereby appointed for a term that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Robin Willig of 3 Bayberry Close is hereby
appointed for a term that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Jason Klein of Valley Terrace is hereby appointed
for a teen that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that Stephanie Fischer of 38 Lawridge Drive is hereby
appointed for a term that will expire on the first Monday in April, 2013; and be it
On a motion made by Trustee Brown, and seconded by Trustee Rednick, the resolutions
were adopted.
The roll was called:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
It was noted that the Environmental Counsel has been reconstituted and charges will be
forthcoming.
Mayor Feinstein thanked everyone for volunteering.
(7) SETTING A PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A NEW FIRE
SERVICES CONTRACT WITH THE VILLAGE OF PORT CHESTER
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 11
Mr. Bradbury read the following resolution:
RESOLUTION
SETTING A PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER A NEW FIRE PROTECTION
AGREEMENT WITH THE VILLAGE OF
PORT CHESTER
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees is considering entering into a renewal
of a three (3)year fire protection agreement with the Village of Port Chester.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees of
the Village of Rye Brook, shall hold a public hearing on May 25, 2010 at 7:30
p.m. at Village Hall, 938 King Street, Rye Brook, New York to consider a new
fire protection agreement with the Village of Port Chester.
Mr. Bradbury noted that this is a wonderful accomplishment. It is a three year
contract with language very similar to the previous contract. He reviewed the
changes for the Board and noted this contract complies with state law that
requires a public hearing be held. The public hearing has been scheduled for May
25.
Mayor Feinstein thanked Mr. Bradbury for his hard work during the negations.
This is a very fair contract for shared services between two municipalities.
On a motion made by Trustee Rednick, and seconded by Trustee Rosenberg, the
resolution was adopted.
Mr. Burke called the roll:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
(8) SETTING A PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER PROPOSED
AMENDMENTS TO THE VILLAGE CODE REGARDING
JURISDICTION OVER AFFORDABLE HOUSING APPROVAL
Mr. Bradbury read the following resolution:
RESOLUTION
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 12
SETTING A PUBLIC HEARING TO CONSIDER PROPOSED AMENDMENTS
TO THE VILLAGE CODE REGARDING JURISDICTION OVER
AFFORDABLE HOUSING APPROVAL
WHEREAS, the Board of Trustees is considering amendments to Chapter
209, Section 1 of the Village Code regarding affordable housing approval.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Board of Trustees
hereby refers the proposed local law to the Planning Board for report and
recommendation; and be it
FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Board of Trustees of the Village of
Rye Brook, shall hold a public hearing on July 13, 2010 at 7:30 p.m. at the
Village Hall, 938 King Street, Rye Brook, New York to consider the proposed
local law.
Mayor Feinstein noted that this matter was addressed by the Board last month.
The ultimate decision will be made by the Board of Trustees. It is not necessary
under the Village's code to refer this to the Planning Board, however, the
Planning Board's chairman is not in agreement with this decision. Therefore, it is
fair practice to refer this matter to the Planning Board for review and discussion.
Mayor Feinstein asked that the date of the public hearing be amended to July 13tH
On a motion made by Trustee Rosenberg, and seconded by Trustee Marrow, the
resolution was amended to July 13th
On a motion made by Trustee Rednick, and seconded by Trustee Marrow, the
resolution was adopted.
Mr. Burke called the roll:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
(9) CONSIDERING THE APPROVAL OF MINUTES: FEBRUARY 9, 2010;
FEBRUARY 23, 2010; MARCH 9, 2010; MARCH 23, 2010; APRIL 27, 2010
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 13
Mayor Feinstein called for comments on the summaries. Trustees Marrow and
Rednick noted that they were not on the Board for several of these meetings, but
both had reviewed the summaries.
The summaries were voted upon separately. The February 9, February 23, March 9 and
March 23 summaries were approved subject to corrections on a motion made by Trustee
Rosenberg, and seconded by Trustee Brown.
Trustee Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Marrow Abstain
Trustee Rednick Abstain
Trustee Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Feinstein Voting Aye
On a motion made by Trustee Rednick, and seconded by Trustee Marrow, the April 27
summary was adopted.
Mr. Burke called the roll:
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
Mayor Feinstein called for the Administrator's Report:
ADMINSTRATOR'S REPORT:
Mr. Bradbury began the administrator's report by noting that the Detention Basin project
at Edgewood is moving along very well. There will be a few punch list items left over
after the end of May, but this project is taking shape. The mature plantings are scheduled
to go in soon.
The Ridge Street resurfacing project is underway. Work will take place from 9:00 a.m. to
4:00 p.m. every day. This is a large project that will cause some disruption throughout
the day.
The Sleep for Solutions event is coming up May 22"d. Residents have been notified. The
insurance is in place and everything is in very good shape for this event.
The Highway Department has completed two passes to pick up debris from the storm in
March. Regular garbage collections are now back on schedule. The Village is working
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 14
on the forms needed for FEMA reimbursement. The funds come 75% from the federal
government and 12 '/z % comes from the State. All over-time costs incurred during storm
clean up should be covered by these funds. Also included will be damages not covered
by insurance.
Trustee Rosenberg stated that the Highway Department has done a fantastic job cleaning
up and picking up garage. There are more trees down from this weekend's storm with
50-60 mile per hour winds. People should be aware that these trees, limbs and branches
should be cut down because there is no more storm clean up. Mayor Feinstein agreed,
noting that this clean up is the responsibility of the residents.
Mayor Feinstein called for the discussion item on the agenda:
DISCUSSION:
1) VILLAGE CODE REQUIREMENTS REGARDING DEAD TREES
Mayor Feinstein noted that she put this matter on the agenda. It was noted that
residents do not need to apply for a permit for a tree that was severely damaged or
knocked down during a storm. It is considered an act of nature and there is no
replanting requirement with removing the tree. She suggested that this portion of
the Village's Code be reviewed.
Trustee Brown noted that trees with root rot that will die require replacement. He
agreed that there is a grey area in the Village's Code.
Mr. Michal Nowak noted that you cannot make a decision by just looking at a
tree. Each basis and/or application is reviewed on its own merit. The Village's
Code calls for a replanting plan when removing a tree.
Mr. Beane noted that after a storm any trees in danger of falling must be taken
down. In this instance there is no replanting requirement. However, if someone
takes a street tree down, there should be some kind of replacement plan. It
behooves the Village to review this portion of the ordinance. It was noted that
this matter required additional review, and it was suggested that it could be
referred to the Environmental Council.
Mayor Feinstein called for members of the public wishing to address the Board. There
being no one, she called for a motion to adjourn. On a motion made by Trustee Rednick,
and seconded by Trustee Marrow, the meeting was adjourned at 9:08 p.m.
Mr. Burke called the roll:
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 15
Trustee Michael S. Brown Voting Aye
Trustee Toby S. Marrow Voting Aye
Trustee Jeffrey B. Rednick Voting Aye
Trustee Paul S. Rosenberg Voting Aye
Mayor Joan L. Feinstein Voting Aye
Board of Trustees Meeting
May 11, 2010
Page 16